REVIEW: Mary Skelter: Nightmares

Wednesday, October 4th, 2017

Share this page

We are proudly a Play-Asia Partner

SUPPORT OPRAINFALL BY TURNING OFF ADBLOCK

Ads support the website by covering server and domain costs. We're just a group of gamers here, like you, doing what we love to do: playing video games and bringing y'all niche goodness. So, if you like what we do and want to help us out, make an exception by turning off AdBlock for our website. In return, we promise to keep intrusive ads, such as pop-ups, off oprainfall. Thanks, everyone!

By


Mary Skelter Nightmares Cover Image
Title Mary Skelter: Nightmares
Developer Compile Heart, Idea Factory
Publisher Idea Factory International
Release Date September 19, 2017
Genre Dungeon Crawler JRPG
Platform PlayStation Vita
Age Rating ESRB M for Mature
Official Website

If you were to poll the general gaming audience as to what the most “hard core” genres are, some likely answers would be Fighting Games and Multiplayer Online Battle Arena (MOBA) Games. But it would not be very far down the list before you came to dungeon crawler RPGs. In fact, it is such a notoriously difficult genre of games that many people just actively avoid them and have never even played one. Part of that notorious difficulty is due to the fact that this is a genre of games that is one of the oldest in all of gaming, I played my first dungeon crawler back in the 1980’s on an Apple IIE computer. And games were generally just made to be a lot more difficult back then. But in the modern world there is also the examples of games like Stranger of Sword City, Demon Gaze, and particularly the Etrian Odyssey games, all of which were quite difficult compared to other games of the current era. There are a few examples where modern developers have tried to make a more simple version of the genre to get more people into it, such as Severed and Persona Q, but for longtime fans the difficulty and grinding is a feature of the genre, not a detraction. So the first part of any dungeon crawler review has to be for which audience it is intended. And in case of Mary Skelter: Nightmares, it is definitely an example of a dungeon crawler that is made for dungeon crawler fans, particularly when you get to the end of the game.

Mary Skelter: Nightmares | Combat

Beneath the very interesting gothic aesthetic, all the hallmarks of the dungeon crawler genre.

Like any other dungeon crawler, you move one square at a time on a grid based map system in first person view. When you meet up with a monster you see a large view of the group of monsters (also in first person view), only ever seeing the character portraits to the side and when you are selecting an ability for them to use. There are some more recent dungeon crawlers that have started to show more of the party members in battle but, especially on handheld systems, that is quite rare. Thankfully one modern feature does make it into Mary Skelter: Nightmares, and that is the game forming a dungeon map for you to bring up at any time. You cannot interact with the map to create any notes for yourself or to create any custom paths, with one exception. You do have the ability to select a point on the map and usually (more on that later) your party will make their way to that point with the safest route possible. The only limitations are that it cannot be blocked by any interactive objects and it has to be a point on the map that you’ve previously explored.

Mary Skelter: Nightmares | Murder Hunt

Escaping the Nightmares starts off fairly easy, but it gets much more difficult.

There are two aspects of Mary Skelter: Nightmares that were largely pulled from the Etrian Odyssey games, the first is devolution (more on that in the next section) and the second is something similar to the FOEs in that series. And that is a really good thing to pull from the EO series, as it’s one of the most popular features. Nightmares in this game are similar to FOEs in that they are very large monsters that you can see from the map screen (all other fights are random) and they can also attack you while in the middle of fighting other creatures if you are in their path of movement. Other than that, they switched things up a little by making the Nightmares creatures that you are required to avoid until you reach the end of the dungeon. It is actually impossible to defeat them until you destroy the core (at the very end of that dungeon). Until that point, if you are attacked by a Nightmare, you have to destroy one of its parts and that will cause the creature to be stunned while it repairs itself. During that time that it’s stunned you have to run away and get around 90 meters away from where the Nightmare is before you can totally escape it. Until you reach the fringe of its zone, the Nightmare will chase you and it will also attack you outside of combat if you are in its line of sight. To add to the terror of these encounters, on any difficulty but Easy, you cannot see the zone’s map while you are running. So you can possibly run right into a dead end and have to fight the creature again to escape in a different direction. Additionally you cannot pull up your menu at all or exit the dungeon while a Nightmare is chasing you. So if you are going to die in this game, that is the most likely cause.

Mary Skelter: Nightmares | Job System

There are several class choices for each character, offering a lot of variety.

On Normal difficulty the Nightmares are really the only thing that is likely to kill you unless you try to skip a whole lot of content. But on Hard mode the game is much more like Etrian Odyssey, where even random bad groupings of enemies can possibly wipe you. In either case, you can mitigate the possible chances of death by using strategic groupings of party members. Each party member has a choice of 5 different Jobs, with those 5 jobs being shared with one of the other Blood Maidens. For instance, Alice and Cinderella have the same set of Jobs (physical attacking classes) while Sleeping Beauty and Kaguya also share a different set of 5 Jobs (ranged attack classes). Additionally there is free DLC that you can download for the game off of PSN that adds a 6th class that every Blood Maiden can use, the Sakura Maiden. Sakura Maidens are unique because they are an all around class that can use a large variety of weapons and are good on the front row or back row with a general good number on all their different base stats. However, they are not a cheat code for the game, they are nowhere near the most powerful class out of any of the Blood Maidens, and it’s best to use them if you want a 5th role in your party that doesn’t match anything you are interested in for that Maiden. So even if you are uninterested in Thumbelina’s mage abilities, you can turn her into a Sakura Maiden and make her into a (serviceable) front line fighter if you still want to use her in your party of five.

Mary Skelter: Nightmares | Cosplay

One of the highlights of the class system is checking out the next cool outfit for your favorites.

You will want to change jobs fairly often, or as often as possible, because you can mix and match the active skills that you gain with each Job. You cannot change the base stats that are part of each Job (some are faster, some have higher defense, etc), and you cannot bring over the passive skills that you learn with each, but the active skills make it a huge incentive to diversify your portfolio. Ideally, if you really want to master this game, you should master all the best active skills and then switch back to a Job that meets the party spot you need. So you can gain a lot of different nice offensive skills as Alice and then turn her back into a Paladin to protect the rest of the party as a tank. That will give you the best of both worlds since she can Intimidate the boss the first round and then spend several rounds still dishing out a lot of damage while she’s still drawing the ire of that enemy. On Easy there isn’t really as much need for strategy in classes, but I really would not recommend playing any dungeon crawler game on Easy, a very large feature of the games is pitting your mind and perseverance against the designers of the brutal dungeons. If you are playing on Hard, or really far on Normal, you may also want to use Devolution. Similar to the EO games, it allows you to regress your character back a set number of levels with the benefit of a slight increase in stats and some bonus skill points (it’s the only way to have enough skill points to actually master all 6 classes).

Mary Skelter: Nightmares | Massacre Mode

Massacre Mode is what can separate which girls you want to be a part of your main party.

To assist you with combating the denizens of the dungeons, your party members build up a blood meter (that you see below each portrait) that acts as basically a Limit Break from the Final Fantasy series, called Massacre Mode. How long each girl stays in Massacre Mode is variable depending on what you do while in that mode, but it only ever lasts for one normal battle or one Nightmare escape sequence. While in Massacre Mode each Blood Maiden has access to an array of super powerful moves that are quite variable in effect depending on which Maiden it is. You can also stop the buildup of blood by having the girls Lick the blood off of each other (you read that right), which gives them character specific buffs. When enemies attack the Maidens they can also randomly cause the blood that is covering them to become corrupted (the blood gauge turns consecutively darker) and there is a higher chance of corruption the harder they get hit as a percentage of their total health. You really do not want them to reach the Massacre Mode state with corrupted blood, if they do there is a high chance they will enter Blood Skelter mode and go berserk, attacking anyone at random (including your own party members).

Mary Skelter: Nightmares | Blood Skelter

You really do not want your Maidens to reach Blood Skelter state.

There is a potential of 10 party members (9 required and 1 hidden and optional), so you are intended to have one of each Job profile in your party of 5. The Massacre abilities can be the difference between which girl you choose to bring along with you in the party. The other 5 Maidens also come with you but only as Partners, and they can occasionally assist your front line girl with a special move of their own. They also earn 50% of the experience that the front line party members do, so at least you can partially keep up with leveling all 10 characters without needing to do a lot of party switching (like in most dungeon crawlers). One last thing I would like to note about the Jobs is that I actually ended up choosing not to have one of each Job structure characters in my party. I decided to remove my mage class characters in favor of having both Alice and Cinderella in my party. If I was playing the game casually, I would not have done that, but I was trying to finish the game a little more quickly for review and 2 physical attackers with the Marshall skills makes the game much faster (although it still took me 115 hours to complete in total).

More Bloody Fun on Page 2 ->

About William Haderlie

Born in the 1970's, I've been an avid participant for much of video game history. A lifetime of being the sort of supergeek entrenched in the sciences and mathematics has not curbed my appreciation for the artistry of video games, cinema, and especially literature.


Pages: 1 2



  • Mr0303

    I’m really enjoying the game so far and it’s possibly my favourite dungeon crawler in terms of systems.

    The usage of blood and balancing the Massacre mode adds another layer of strategy to the gameplay. The random Jail bonuses can really help you out in a tough spot. So far I felt no need to grind – just getting through the dungeon gives you enough experience to not be under-levelled for the guardian/Nightmare. I like how the jobs are handled – you can learn all the best active skills while keeping the best passive ones. One nitpick I have with them is that they are a bit costly to purchase and you are not exactly sure how useful they are (this may be a reason to grind a bit).

    In terms of characters I like everyone who I’ve met so far bar Kaguya and Jack, who as the review mentioned is a bit too nice, passive and timid. Here’s a drinking game – take a shot every time he says “Sorry.”.

    I found the I found the auto path criticisms a bit too harsh – it is a great time saver, plus realistically I didn’t expect it to deal with all the traps and gimmicks. I did encounter some issues with the larger dungeons (the Temple). While the auto path works, reusing Alice’s Rabbit Hole skill can freeze the game (which could be painful since you are likely to lose a lot of playtime). I don’t think dungeons of that size are really necessary or that fun to do. At some point they are just confusing with double and triple portal paths.

    The good ending conditions sound a bit convoluted, but hopefully I’ll get one of those.

    Overall I think this game is a must for fans of dungeon crawling.

  • Mr0303

    As for the voice acting point – I do like the English dub and I doubt the racket bullies from SAG could’ve improved it in any way.

    • Steve Baltimore

      I didn’t miss Noire’s old VA in CyberNep is all I’m saying.

    • Mr0303

      I’m usually for VAs keeping their roles, but everyone is replaceable.