Character Battle: Xenoblade Chronicles vs The Last Story

Monday, October 22nd, 2012

Share this page

We are proudly a Play-Asia Partner

SUPPORT OPRAINFALL BY TURNING OFF ADBLOCK

Ads support the website by covering server and domain costs. We're just a group of gamers here, like you, doing what we love to do: playing video games and bringing y'all niche goodness. So, if you like what we do and want to help us out, make an exception by turning off AdBlock for our website. In return, we promise to keep intrusive ads, such as pop-ups, off oprainfall. Thanks, everyone!

By


BATTLE 6: The Mystic 

MIRANIA

MELIA

 

 

 

VS

 

 

 

 

 

The Mystics are the characters that are ‘ones with the earth’, that control the power of the elements and that should probably belong in the school of Hogwarts. What they lack in physical strength they make up for it with their powerful magic.

Melia has been sheltered from the ‘outside’ world for most of her life. She is the ‘High Princess’ of Alcamoth and acts very much like one. She is overly formal, a little pompous and has a hard time understanding how non-Alcamothians live. However, over time she becomes accustomed to the ways of the commoner and soon loses her brat-like attitude. Melia controls the many elements of a JRPG world – fire, water, earth, wind, ice and bolt, as well as a few other tricks. She’s great for long-range attacks and against enemies that are we weak to certain elements. Her main disadvantage is her low health and defence, which can prove problematic with some of the tougher bosses, but keep her at a safe distance and she becomes a great asset to your team.

Mirana is a funny old soul. Like Melia she is ‘one with the earth’, with her main magic attack actually being ‘earth’ and she can also heal party members during battle – nothing new there. But what makes Mirania so ‘interesting’ is that she sounds constantly stoned when she speaks. She is invariably away with the fairies, throughout the entire game, and is always on the lookout for food – which is more evidence to add to her being ‘high’. Having said that, Mirania is perhaps one of the most useful characters, to have in your team, due to her ability to revive KO’d teammates. Not only does she revive any companion that has fallen, she also gives full health back to every party member, including herself. Very handy.

Does Melia’s pompousness float your boat or is a constantly stoned Mirania more your style? VOTE NOW!

Who wins?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Dare you enter PAGE 7?

About David Rawlings

David Rawlings, or ‘Rawky’ as we like to call him, joined the Operation Rainfall Campaign at the beginning. He’s British and found solace with us as he was able to understand our pain about Nintendo and their localizing faux pas. He’s a big fan of the letter ‘U’ and refuses to remove them from words, even though we constantly ask him to. He also believes it’s about time Princess Daisy got kidnapped.


Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7



  • I generally voted for The Last Story characters in this one.  I just prefer The Last Story to Xenoblade.  That said, did Syrenne remind anyone of Bender from Futurama?  They were both foul mouthed and ran on alcohol!

  • Last Story’s characters put Xeno to shame. If there was one driving force in TLS, it was the characters.

  • I can deal Riki’s ‘annoyance’ because he’s one of the best characters in the game. 

  • It was kinda a tie between Riki (hilarious but deeply sympathetic creature) and Yurick (who had a moment of character development + depth). As for the others, Xenoblade Chronicles!
    It’s just that in my opinion, the Xenoblade Chronicles characters have more depth in general than those of TLS game. Secondly, if I ever go on a JRPG adventure, I’d rather travel with the determined destiny-breakers than some Zelos Wilder-reject (no offence Lowell), Rangiku Matsumoto’s sister, too-naive/ignorant princess (hell, Luke fon Fabre was as just naive/ignorant, but we all know that the guy became a major hero-boss) and a Rei Ayanami girl.
    Okay, that leaves Zael and Dagran, but they both can’t be compared to Shulk and Dunban, though, Zael is probably my most favourite hero of The Last Story.

  • John Ellis

    Some of these choices are hard, with Mystics  I was very tempted by Melia, what with her being a well defined character, but I went with Mirania since she’s so funny, plus the women who voiced her was in Ashes to Ashes:)

  • Jono

    Xenoblade won every won by a long shot, except the Love Interest (I LOVED Calista, and Fiora really annoyed me sometimes) and the companion (Yurick is probably my favorite character of either game; his great voice actor probably had something to do with that, and the fact that he wasn’t a one-sided character in the slightest.)

  • My god the simliarity between the characters in each game are hilarious and uncanny. I’ve yet to play Xenoblade Chronicles, so I can’t compare most of the characters… but from what I’ve read, last story characters seem far more interesting most of the time.. especially the leads x.x

  • I went with Shulk for the first one. Zael’s selflessness allowed him to become a knight and (presumably) leader of Lazulis Island. Shulk’s determination allowed him to create his own Monado and become a God in his own right.
    Calista, hands down, no competition. Fiora’s cool, but she just doesn’t match up to noble who can kick ass and take names. Plus, I love that she can summon a beast to your aid; that was one of the things I loved about Yuna in FF:X.

    Much as I love Dunban, Dagran does an amazing job leading his mercenary group. He’s always securing jobs from clients so they can actually feed themselves without so much as a “thank you” from the rest of the troupe. Dunban is handy in battle and a good person to talk to; Dagran has both those qualities and more.

    Again, hands down to Lowell. Lowell’s accent just makes his lines that much funnier, and his constant banter with Syrenne is just fantastic. xD I do still love Reyn, but Lowell is just funnier.

    Sharla – after all she’s been through, she’s still able to keep a level head and hold it up high. I love Syrenne’s character, and she makes me laugh, but I admire Sharla so much more for her inner strength. Plus, she makes a great healer!

    <3 Mirania. As someone who loves nature and the outdoors, this was a no-brainer for me. I also like the way she's seemingly spaced out all the time. xD Melia's cool, but her low HP and defensive stats really irritate me. So does her inability to tell Shulk how she feels, and then losing her chance. I did feel a little sorry for her, but come on man. 

    Riki and Yurick… it was hard to choose between the two, but I eventually settled on Riki because he, at least, is jovial. I'm not a fan of his immaturity though. Yurick's cynicism really ticked me off, as did the fact that he was so closed to everyone for a long while; he did end up opening up a little at the end though. I have to say, I did really enjoy that sidequest where you go into the haunted mansion, if only to see Yurick get the pants scared off him.

  • Dunban. Loved him at the start and loved him at the end.

  • As the author of this article, I am unable to vote, but incase you were all wondering my choices would be:

    Shulk, Fiora, Dunban, Reyn, Syrenne, Mirania and Yurick

  • DunbansBiggestFanForever

    Awesome article. I personally love all the characters equally. But Xenoblade I liked a tad more. 

  • DunbansBiggestFanForever

    DUNBAN ALL THE WAAAAAAAAAAAAY Dagran you can go die lol 

  • DunbansBiggestFanForever

    Mirania…nuff said. Melia I love you but its just the way it has to be. 

  • Voted mostly for Xenoblade other than Miriana just because she was pretty and had a lovely voice.

  • These were tough for me. I haven’t voted for any of them yet because I can only say for sure that I’d vote for Lowell. They’re all good at what they do.

  • Most people are going to vote according to which game they liked more, not which individual characters are the best independent of the game, so  most votes will go to Xenoblade being that it is the more popular of the two games.

    • You’d think that. But check out the current results, its pretty close.

  • air_dex

    Not especially agree with all the associations :
    – Shulk vs. Zael , Dunban vs. Dagran and Reyn vs. Lowell : that’s OK for me. Hero vs. Hero, Leader vs. Leader and Badass vs. Badass (not jokers, especially for Reyn).
    – Fiora vs. Callista : disagree. A “Princess vs. Princess” Melia vs. Callista would be better.
    – Melia vs. Mirania : they have nothing in common. Mirania is closer to Sharla than Melia (“happy” childhood and they care for people). A “Medic battle” Sharla vs. Mirania is more logical.
    – Sharla vs. Syrenne : why not for the girl power, but Sharla’s better battle is versus Mirania, so this battle is not convenient. A “Fiora vs. Syrenne” for Girl Power or a “Riki vs. Syrenne” for being the most effusive person of the team are better batlles for Syrenne. If non playable characters are included, why not a “Fiora vs. Meredith”.
    – Riki vs.Yurick : nothing in common, so there is no reason to get such a battle. Riki and Yurick are more convenient for battles with non playable characters of both games. Battles like “Alvis vs.Yurick” for the Mystic and “Riki vs. Horace” for a real sidekick battle are more logical.

  • sersvweytbrv

    dvgasdfhsbnrtebhtrgvfryer werwer
    3

    342
    45 7
    45
    wr6
    4bvg5
    bv
    webhy
    egvtfdbthu